Skip to main content
Home Conservation Forums

Sen. Brown Exposes NOAA's Illicit Party Boat

mjacksmjacks Posts: 152 Deckhand
Sen. Brown Exposes NOAA's Illicit Party Boat
Washington, DC - February 17, 2012 -- Yesterday, U.S. Senator Scott Brown (R-MA) filed a Freedom of Information Act request for an Inspector General report on the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA) illicit purchase and use of a $300,000 luxury fishing boat. The request was granted, and today Senator Brown spoke from the Senate floor to reveal the numerous abuses detailed in the previously unknown findings of the Inspector General.

The following are the Senator's remarks as prepared for delivery on the Senate floor:

I rise today to inform you and the public of some highly disturbing information that I've just learned about a broken agency within our federal government - The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).

We all know that Washington doesn't spend our money wisely. But sometimes it is worth highlighting examples of the corruption and waste.

Yesterday morning, I contacted the Commerce Department Inspector General to request a copy of their report on NOAA's purchase of a $300,000 luxury boat.

It would be bad enough if they had purchased this boat with taxpayer dollars.

But they didn't. They paid for it with money that should belong to our struggling fishermen. They paid for it out of the fines that fishermen pay into the pot when they mistakenly catch the wrong kind of fish. Those dollars are supposed to stay in fishing communities to help the fishermen.

Here's the boat. For a government vessel, that's pretty flashy. Take a look inside. That's a fully-appointed bar, the latest in on-board entertainment systems, and leather furniture complete with the ice chest and tackle rack.

Furthermore, the fines that fishermen have been paying are putting fishermen out of business. The stories will break your heart.

So let me again describe the situation: NOAA levied totally unreasonable fines against our fishermen. Then they used that money to buy themselves a luxury boat. So what else did the IG investigation find? Mr. President, here are the disturbing headlines.

According to the IG, NOAA had no reasonable official use for this boat. Let's start there. They didn't need it. Period. They had some story about needing an "undercover vessel" to sneak up on whale watching vessels. Imagine that - armed federal agents sneaking up on school groups and tourists trying to learn about nature. The IG found this to be as ridiculous. NOAA officials wanted this useless luxury boat, then they invented a reason to buy it with fishermen's hard-earned dollars.

So why did NOAA go to such lengths to "manipulate" and "violate" the government purchasing rules to get this boat? NOAA already has many boats and more cars than it has agents, so why add this to the inventory? Well, Mr. President, they apparently didn't need it for official purposes. We know that because the IG says that it was never - I repeat, never - used for official business.

The sad truth is that it was a fishermen-funded party boat for bureaucrats, Mr. President. That's right, while fishermen in Gloucester and New Bedford are struggling to put off foreclosure or mourning the loss of their livelihood because of NOAA's overzealous enforcement, the NOAA office was living the good life on their dime.

NOAA officials used the boat for the following: trips to dockside restaurants; hamburger and hotdog BBQs and alcohol-fueled parties and with family and friends; and "pleasure cruises" at high rates of speed, with beer consumed on-board.

Even though federal rules ban non-employees from being on vessels, a NOAA supervisor even told a subordinate that his wife was welcome to "kick back and watch TV" on the boat.

They filed expense reports and reimbursed themselves for these trips.

What excuse did NOAA employees give for this behavior? They needed to do all these things to maintain the recreational appearance of this "undercover" boat that was never even used for the "undercover" work that it was supposedly purchased for.

Mr. President, let's be honest. A booze cruise is a booze cruise.

One NOAA officer decided to take his family on a weekend trip to a posh resort. He took the undercover NOAA party boat to get there, but he was untrained in how to operate it and blew out a $30,000 engine. Rather than turn back and write the taxpayers a check, he simply abandoned it and took a marked NOAA law enforcement boat the rest of the way to their resort. Nothing could get between this NOAA employee and a good time. When asked about that incident, the NOAA employee lied to the IG and said there was no family on board. That was just one of many instances of NOAA employees deliberately misleading the IG.

Another NOAA officer used the undercover NOAA boat to take his wife to lunch in Seattle. On this trip, the boat engines stalled in a shipping lane because the boat ran out of fuel due to another operator error. The guy didn't know how to switch the tanks. So they were stuck drifting in a dangerous shipping lane. The officer and his wife apparently found the situation comical. Well I don't think that the fishermen in New Bedford are laughing.

Again - the money that belonged to fishermen was paying for all this.

To this day, Mr. President, no one has been held accountable. Let me repeat. No one has been disciplined, fired, or even reprimanded for anything having to do with this boat. As you've seen here today, NOAA has a culture of corruption that has created a chasm of distrust between the agency and the fishing industry.

Here is a list of all the problems I have encountered with NOAA since coming to the Senate: abusive treatment of fishermen, resulting in decimation of the fleet; investigations motivated by money; improper fines, leading to foreclosure and bankruptcy; "shredding parties" destroying 75%-80% of OLE documents; lying to Inspector General investigators; discouraging cooperation with the Inspector General; misleading Members of Congress; $300,000 party boat purchased with fishermen's fines; $12,000 in party boat expenses paid with fishermen's fines; $30,000 engine destroyed by NOAA employee on weekend vacation while using "undercover" NOAA craft.

This is simply unacceptable. This needs to change, and accountability starts at the top. NOAA's leadership needs to change.

I am calling once more for President Obama to fire NOAA administrator Jane Lubchenco.

If not now, when? If not for this, then for what?

Our fishermen and the American taxpayers deserve better from their Federal Government.

Watch the Senator's address on the Senate floor:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIdzt...ature=youtu.be

Replies

  • OysterbottomboyOysterbottomboy Posts: 414 Officer
    I couldn't see the link. I hope to god they fire that evil women!
  • 9-Lives9-Lives Posts: 2,124 Captain
    here's a working link:

    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIdzt53FKtY


    Sen. Brown


    Deleted my whole post...... What's the point :Horse
    marlin_baitball.gif
  • CaptBlazeCaptBlaze Posts: 96 Deckhand
    I would love to hear the "other side of the story" from the NOAA officers that cruise this forum. And their explanation of why they need a 32 foot Whaler with Trip 300's on it, so they can run it aground, and take their wives on weekend boat rides...
  • You won't.

    Its "above their pay grade".
    "If I can't win, I won't play." - Doris Colecchio.

    "Well Gary, the easiest way to look tall is to stand in a room full of short people." - Curtis Bostick

    "All these forums, with barely any activity, are like a neglected old cemetery that no one visits anymore."- anonymouse
  • Saltydog83Saltydog83 Posts: 94 Greenhorn
    :wink
    mjacks wrote: »
    Sen. Brown Exposes NOAA's Illicit Party Boat
    Washington, DC - February 17, 2012 -- Yesterday, U.S. Senator Scott Brown (R-MA) filed a Freedom of Information Act request for an Inspector General report on the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration's (NOAA) illicit purchase and use of a $300,000 luxury fishing boat. The request was granted, and today Senator Brown spoke from the Senate floor to reveal the numerous abuses detailed in the previously unknown findings of the Inspector General.

    The following are the Senator's remarks as prepared for delivery on the Senate floor:

    I rise today to inform you and the public of some highly disturbing information that I've just learned about a broken agency within our federal government - The National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration (NOAA).

    We all know that Washington doesn't spend our money wisely. But sometimes it is worth highlighting examples of the corruption and waste.

    Yesterday morning, I contacted the Commerce Department Inspector General to request a copy of their report on NOAA's purchase of a $300,000 luxury boat.

    It would be bad enough if they had purchased this boat with taxpayer dollars.

    But they didn't. They paid for it with money that should belong to our struggling fishermen. They paid for it out of the fines that fishermen pay into the pot when they mistakenly catch the wrong kind of fish. Those dollars are supposed to stay in fishing communities to help the fishermen.

    Here's the boat. For a government vessel, that's pretty flashy. Take a look inside. That's a fully-appointed bar, the latest in on-board entertainment systems, and leather furniture complete with the ice chest and tackle rack.

    Furthermore, the fines that fishermen have been paying are putting fishermen out of business. The stories will break your heart.

    So let me again describe the situation: NOAA levied totally unreasonable fines against our fishermen. Then they used that money to buy themselves a luxury boat. So what else did the IG investigation find? Mr. President, here are the disturbing headlines.

    According to the IG, NOAA had no reasonable official use for this boat. Let's start there. They didn't need it. Period. They had some story about needing an "undercover vessel" to sneak up on whale watching vessels. Imagine that - armed federal agents sneaking up on school groups and tourists trying to learn about nature. The IG found this to be as ridiculous. NOAA officials wanted this useless luxury boat, then they invented a reason to buy it with fishermen's hard-earned dollars.

    So why did NOAA go to such lengths to "manipulate" and "violate" the government purchasing rules to get this boat? NOAA already has many boats and more cars than it has agents, so why add this to the inventory? Well, Mr. President, they apparently didn't need it for official purposes. We know that because the IG says that it was never - I repeat, never - used for official business.

    The sad truth is that it was a fishermen-funded party boat for bureaucrats, Mr. President. That's right, while fishermen in Gloucester and New Bedford are struggling to put off foreclosure or mourning the loss of their livelihood because of NOAA's overzealous enforcement, the NOAA office was living the good life on their dime.

    NOAA officials used the boat for the following: trips to dockside restaurants; hamburger and hotdog BBQs and alcohol-fueled parties and with family and friends; and "pleasure cruises" at high rates of speed, with beer consumed on-board.

    Even though federal rules ban non-employees from being on vessels, a NOAA supervisor even told a subordinate that his wife was welcome to "kick back and watch TV" on the boat.

    They filed expense reports and reimbursed themselves for these trips.

    What excuse did NOAA employees give for this behavior? They needed to do all these things to maintain the recreational appearance of this "undercover" boat that was never even used for the "undercover" work that it was supposedly purchased for.

    Mr. President, let's be honest. A booze cruise is a booze cruise.

    One NOAA officer decided to take his family on a weekend trip to a posh resort. He took the undercover NOAA party boat to get there, but he was untrained in how to operate it and blew out a $30,000 engine. Rather than turn back and write the taxpayers a check, he simply abandoned it and took a marked NOAA law enforcement boat the rest of the way to their resort. Nothing could get between this NOAA employee and a good time. When asked about that incident, the NOAA employee lied to the IG and said there was no family on board. That was just one of many instances of NOAA employees deliberately misleading the IG.

    Another NOAA officer used the undercover NOAA boat to take his wife to lunch in Seattle. On this trip, the boat engines stalled in a shipping lane because the boat ran out of fuel due to another operator error. The guy didn't know how to switch the tanks. So they were stuck drifting in a dangerous shipping lane. The officer and his wife apparently found the situation comical. Well I don't think that the fishermen in New Bedford are laughing.

    Again - the money that belonged to fishermen was paying for all this.

    To this day, Mr. President, no one has been held accountable. Let me repeat. No one has been disciplined, fired, or even reprimanded for anything having to do with this boat. As you've seen here today, NOAA has a culture of corruption that has created a chasm of distrust between the agency and the fishing industry.

    Here is a list of all the problems I have encountered with NOAA since coming to the Senate: abusive treatment of fishermen, resulting in decimation of the fleet; investigations motivated by money; improper fines, leading to foreclosure and bankruptcy; "shredding parties" destroying 75%-80% of OLE documents; lying to Inspector General investigators; discouraging cooperation with the Inspector General; misleading Members of Congress; $300,000 party boat purchased with fishermen's fines; $12,000 in party boat expenses paid with fishermen's fines; $30,000 engine destroyed by NOAA employee on weekend vacation while using "undercover" NOAA craft.

    This is simply unacceptable. This needs to change, and accountability starts at the top. NOAA's leadership needs to change.

    I am calling once more for President Obama to fire NOAA administrator Jane Lubchenco.

    If not now, when? If not for this, then for what?

    Our fishermen and the American taxpayers deserve better from their Federal Government.

    Watch the Senator's address on the Senate floor:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lIdzt...ature=youtu.be
  • Gary S. ColecchioGary S. Colecchio Posts: 24,905 AG
    "If I can't win, I won't play." - Doris Colecchio.

    "Well Gary, the easiest way to look tall is to stand in a room full of short people." - Curtis Bostick

    "All these forums, with barely any activity, are like a neglected old cemetery that no one visits anymore."- anonymouse
  • :puke It makes me sick when I see fishing brothers supporting the left. They cant understand they are supporting a group that wants a police state funded by us!
  • Still waiting for someone from NOAA to give us their side.

    http://www.americanthinker.com/2012/03/noaas_party_boat.html

    They have neither the balls nor the stomach to admit to us their agenda. Crabtree for one is a **** and a liar.
  • SpectacularVSpectacularV Posts: 136 Officer
    There is certainly another side. I have a Boston Whaler and I can tell you that the pictures that he is showing are directly from the Boston Whaler Brochure. Call up Whaler to get your brochure today. Whalers govermental versions are really bare and stripped down. Much different from a BROCHURE SENATOR. He must think that we are all IDIOTS to buy his representation through use of a STANDARD BROCHURE.

    Therefore this Senator is a Misleading the public by showing this picture. A clear mis representation and lack of understanding that the GOVERNMENT outfitted boats are used EVERYDAY not once a month over the next 5-10 years.

    I know that in Louisiana they purchased 11 Whaler 320's Government version for there wildlife department. They are decked and I am sure they cost at least $160,000ea. Here in Fort Lauderdale and Broward county they patrol in INTREPEDS but they are far from the pure customs versions.

    Would we rather these guys respond to calls and patrol in BAYLINERS on the water EVERYDAY? Maybe they should just swim to the next MAYDAY Call in 6 foot seas.

    Maybe Fireman should arrive by Horse and Buggy and not their $1,000,000 Fire Trucks.

    Maybe Police Officers can patrol on Skate Boards instead of their $80,000 police cars.

    There is a lot of government waste but this Senator is not completely truthful. What a snake.

    What amazes me is how many of us swallow these reports hook line and sinker without question.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • Gary S. ColecchioGary S. Colecchio Posts: 24,905 AG
    We all know that that is a stock photo. The site referenced it. Show us a photo of the specific boat , not another stock photo, of the boat in question.
    "If I can't win, I won't play." - Doris Colecchio.

    "Well Gary, the easiest way to look tall is to stand in a room full of short people." - Curtis Bostick

    "All these forums, with barely any activity, are like a neglected old cemetery that no one visits anymore."- anonymouse
  • backwatersrulebackwatersrule Posts: 12 Greenhorn
    It makes me sick when I see fishing brothers supporting the right. They cant understand they are supporting a group that wants a police state funded by us!
  • EggsuckindogEggsuckindog Posts: 1,526 Captain
    They are decked and I am sure they cost at least $160,000ea.


    Well just to put a stop to this ca ca - this particular one cost 300 grand, the bar and DVD stuff adds right up

    you wouldn't happen to be a public employee would you? I'm sure not
    1976 SeaCraft master Angler - Merc 200 XRi
    dscf1243-1.jpg
  • SpectacularVSpectacularV Posts: 136 Officer
    They are decked and I am sure they cost at least $160,000ea.


    Well just to put a stop to this ca ca - this particular one cost 300 grand, the bar and DVD stuff adds right up

    you wouldn't happen to be a public employee would you? I'm sure not

    No Just a Tax Payer in the highest bracket. I agree that the boat cost $300,000 if not more; but the DELIBERATE CHARACTERIZATION that it is a luxury boat is FACTUALLY MISLEADING. Call this CA CA if you want but this is the calling card of IDIOT POLITICIANS. Taking half truths and converting them into EXAGGERATED LIES.

    The misuse of the boat by employees is equally appauling if true.

    A police car is a needed piece of equipment,but if it is misused, it does not mean it is not needed.
    A Fire Truck is a needed piece of equipment, but if it is misused, it does not mean it ts not needed.

    Having been in the Pacific Ocean a few times a boat with this stature is needed. If you have the time you can visit the BRUNSWICK COMMERCIAL & GOVERNMENTAL website and take a look at more accurate depiction of the boat (CHALLENGER 350). I know some folks in the northwest that have seen these boats and they are not what this Senator was selling to the PUBLIC.

    I'm ok with you wanting NOAA and our local fisheries/governments to patrol in BAYLINER type boats; As a Fisherman and Boater I am not. I do not believe in waste or accept misuse of taxpayer funding, But I HATE POLITICIANS who outright LIE to us. I dont buy anything that BOENER or OBAMA, CNN or FOX sells me without checking my self if its important.

    I URGE MORE of you to DO the SAME. Thats SMART not CA CA.
    [SIGPIC][/SIGPIC]
  • sk018sk018 Posts: 2,958 Captain
    I agree with Spectacular 100%...However if even some of these allegations are true about the parties etc that is appaling!
  • Fear KnotFear Knot Posts: 151 Officer
    Why am I not surprised....way to go Sen Brown.
  • Fear KnotFear Knot Posts: 151 Officer
    You won't.

    Its "above their pay grade".
    LOL..or "i could tell you but I'd have to kill you" attitude.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

Preview This Month's Issue

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Florida Sportsman App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Florida Sportsman stories delivered right to your inbox.

Advertisement

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Florida Sportsman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now