Home General Freshwater Fishing

Had a Carppy Day

Went to a pond by me with a dock ill sometimes fish from when I want to soak a baitfish while I do school crap. Had a brim out (couldnt get any shiners they had moved deep, my friend had caught six and he had been there for 3 hours) and started doing some school work. Someone I hadn't met yet came over and we started talking fishing. About fifteen minutes later my friend left and the guy started throwing out some stale bread he had, I think it was cuban bread. Well shortly after he says he thinks he sees some carp so I get up and sure enough theres a couple. I seem them probably every three times I go there but they always just cruise on by, I'll throw bread at them but hadn't ever seen them eat it. Well there was a good amount of bread already out there, alot of it floating far out, and they started eating it. So im like ill be damned i reel in my bluegill, huck it, and the guy gives me a piece of bread. It was from a loaf of very stale bread with a toasted outside, maybe it was puerto rican bread? (ive got some like it at wal mart before). Well I put it on my 4/0 shiner hook, wet it so i can cast decent, and cast it out and its actually floating!

About a minute later a carp inhales it, set the hook and got a couple fun runs before it started to tire a bit. I'm laughing my **** off, i couldn't believe i had actually caught one of these particular carp (i thought they didn't really eat the bread people throw out much, they're always cruising) and im starting to reel it to shore and notice another bigger carp is with it and staying real close to hit. I'm like **** i wonder.......i run to my car while the guy that was there is holding my rod and grab another rod outta it. Run back and throw another piece of bread on. This one didn't seem like it was gonna eat it, it seemed focused on the other carp, but about two minutes later it just explodes on it. The guy was saying "Man that looked like a shark hitting that" ive never seen a carp hit topwater, it was pretty exciting, anyway, set the hook and had a fun fight with it.

Well then long story short i jumped down from the dock, went on a sandbar next to it about 2" deep and started to land the smaller one. I got it almost beached and stupidly decided to grab the line to pull it in instead of using the road. Well it took off, went by the dock, and cut through my 20lb power pro like a knife. Oh well, at least it was the smaller one. Landed the other one though, was 14lb 2oz, beat my personal best by 1lb. I was expecting I wasnt gonna get anything today, unfortunately they weren't bass but was a pleasant surprise!




  • RemoteRedsTroutRemoteRedsTrout Posts: 408 Deckhand
    Oh and i kept it cooked m up on the grill. Filleted, used some old bay and secret seasonings, and threw on a cedar plank for about 15 minutes. Took off the grill, threw away the fish, and ate the cedar plank. From what ive heard carp tastes like crap! and really boney
  • johnDjohnD WC FLPosts: 6,427 Admiral
    lesson learned :rotflmao

    you might wanna stick to the reds and trout lol !!

    nice fish though.
  • RemoteRedsTroutRemoteRedsTrout Posts: 408 Deckhand
    Hahahahaha thanks man
  • BigRed03BigRed03 Posts: 8 Greenhorn
    Nice carp!

    I've used a similar method to catch the grass carp (that size and bigger) in the canals down here in Miami/Broward. They'll eat bread for sure, but not at first, takes them a while to realize its food.
  • IshIsh Posts: 797 Officer
    That is a awesome story and nice pics .
  • RemoteRedsTroutRemoteRedsTrout Posts: 408 Deckhand
    Thank you, I love when I hook into a fish and have other ones follow it to shore! Ive got some good bass by grabbing another rod and casting out when they are following the one i got a hook in

    Anyone know of any other kinds of bread thatll float on a hook?
  • Martin LocalMartin Local Posts: 557 Officer
    thats funny. up by me we saw some fish rolling in brackish water and couldn't figure out what they were, but we noticed they were eating acornes off an oak tree hanging over the water and when they fell off the tree they were rolling like a tarpon and eating them. so we drilled holes in acornes and put a circle hook through them and tossed them out under the oak tree and sure enough we hooked up and finally got it in and it was huge carp.i mean huge 30 -40-50 +++pound ones. we did it all day and caught tons of them. one of the wierdest things i did while fishing all these years, but it was fun.
  • bigfinn35bigfinn35 Sarasota/VenicePosts: 950 Officer
    Nice! There a pond behind my house with huge grass carp, easily 30 lbs. Fished for them with bread, dough, corn, algae, and tomatoes and only landed 1 in 4 years.
    Paddle faster, I hear banjo music.
  • ShallowatrShallowatr Posts: 60 Deckhand
    Dog food pellets have worked for me in the past
  • RemoteRedsTroutRemoteRedsTrout Posts: 408 Deckhand
    bigfinn35 wrote: »
    Nice! There a pond behind my house with huge grass carp, easily 30 lbs. Fished for them with bread, dough, corn, algae, and tomatoes and only landed 1 in 4 years.

    I feel your pain. I used to live in an apartment complex with what seemed like newly stocked grass carp mostly around 4-6lbs. My friend lived in a complex with some big ones. These fish would eat but it seemed like it was only because people regularly fed them old bread. Ive come across some monsters in alotta ponds where people don't feed them and tried throwing bread out not even on a hook and they wouldn't have it. it seems they need to be conditioned to see bread as a food source. i always chum with bread/dough/etc. before i cast out and wait until i see them eating my chum. on a side note, the first one i caught i sight fished, then went about 50 feet down the bank then started throwing chum out so i didnt spook it. i threw bread, peanuts, and stale muffins all over the place then put a big compacted bread ball on a hook and threw out. they are some of the spookiest fish ever, it seems you really cant cast less than 50feet from them without them spooking sometimes. and if they see you moving, they'll usually spook. but im not much of a carp fisherman so i dont know if this is all true....
  • kahmadkahmad Posts: 235 Officer
    I've eaten carp before and it's really not all that bad. The thing about carp is you can't really "fillet" them because of the way their bones are shaped. In Germany they cook the carp whole and just take chunks off of it.

    Down here in broward I occasionally see a massive grass carp or two lumbering by but they are very hard to catch. They don't reproduce because they're triploid (the FWC made them that way) so there aren't too many of them numbers wise, but when you do get one it's always a nice rush.
  • maddoxrjmaddoxrj Posts: 113 Officer
    That's a really cool report. I've never been able to get them to bite...I guess I should have tried acorns.
  • TrophyRoomAppTrophyRoomApp Posts: 172 Deckhand
    Nice Catch !
    Do You Hunt Or Fish & Own An iPhone? http://www.TrophyRoomApp.com
Sign In or Register to comment.
Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!


Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

Preview This Month's Issue

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Florida Sportsman App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Florida Sportsman stories delivered right to your inbox.


Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Florida Sportsman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now