HAHA, after seeing Lostconch's response and rereading OP's question I realized the question was about bait and not lures. Down through the years for me the best live bait has been situation specific on the SE Fl coast, fall bait migrations on the beach and at inlets, other times of the year at inlets, when a spillway is open, lighted docks at night, bridges, or mangroves and oyster bars all have the best bait for that circumstance. Match the hatch is good old saying.
I agree you’re correct that bait and lures are different. However, I grew up fishing topwater “baits”. It was most probably just a colloquial expression. We called our tackle box a bait box as well. Sounds a little backwards today.
I love the way snook attack a full sized Skitterwalk but I don't like how fragile they are (a few good sized snook leaves the plug with one or two cracks in it most days). When you get a bit of water into the plug you don't get many strikes -but until then nothing beats it for topwater snook strikes when it's brand new...
My anglers tangle with snook using live bait, dead bait, lures, flies (in other words every way possible..). Much as I love a topwater bite - most of our fish come on lures or flies that aren't at the surface (and most our big snook come to live or fresh dead cut bait year after year..).
Day trips out of Flamingo or Chokoloskee - night trips out Miami or Jupiter...
Well there you go, guys. It's gospel if Capt. Bob says skitterwalk! Click, clack, click, clack, pause, click, BOOM! The strike is the best part for me on a topwater, whether you catch the fish or not.
And for those who've never "walked the dog" with a Spook, Skitterwalk, Top Dog (or any of the other nice fat stickbaits..). vary your retrieve a bit - particularly with a bit of stop and go every now and then... That stopping and starting routine draws strikes (understatement...).
When we work one of them for tarpon it's different - with a slow lazy retrieve (like you didn't care if you ever got a bite...) but never ever stop the retrieve - and expect the first strike to be a bit short. If you keep that plug moving slow and steady, walking the dog they rarely miss the second strike...
Or a nice live bait - in my area, the backcountry of the 'glades we mostly use live ladyfish...
The truth is most really big fish will scavenge up a good sized fresh cutbait - since they just can't get enough to eat. That includes giant tarpon, snook, redfish, jack crevalle - and many, many other species... We only use cutbait, though, in a spot with some current. No moving water - don't bother using cutbait at all...
All Florida Sportsman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.
To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.
Replies
My anglers tangle with snook using live bait, dead bait, lures, flies (in other words every way possible..). Much as I love a topwater bite - most of our fish come on lures or flies that aren't at the surface (and most our big snook come to live or fresh dead cut bait year after year..).
Day trips out of Flamingo or Chokoloskee - night trips out Miami or Jupiter...
Bob LeMay
(954) 435-5666
When we work one of them for tarpon it's different - with a slow lazy retrieve (like you didn't care if you ever got a bite...) but never ever stop the retrieve - and expect the first strike to be a bit short. If you keep that plug moving slow and steady, walking the dog they rarely miss the second strike...
Bob LeMay
(954) 435-5666
The truth is most really big fish will scavenge up a good sized fresh cutbait - since they just can't get enough to eat. That includes giant tarpon, snook, redfish, jack crevalle - and many, many other species... We only use cutbait, though, in a spot with some current. No moving water - don't bother using cutbait at all...
Bob LeMay
(954) 435-5666