Creamy or Crunchy

cadman

Seeing a member call creamy peanut butter children's food it made me wonder which people prefer. I always thought the crunchy was for the kids myself. Creamy is the only way for an adult to go. 

So which do you prefer?

Mister-Jr

Creamy Peanut Butter

I eat a lot of peanut butter on bread, apples, bananas, and right off the spoon, always creamy.

Tarpon65

I like both, but we usually have creamy in the house as that is what the wife prefers.  

dave44

Crunchy Peanut Butter

Crunchy. Mmmmm. Or creamy. I’m not sure I really care as long as it’s peanut butter.

stc1993

I eat Peter Pan honey roast.  Once you eat it you'll never eat regular pb again.

cadman

Creamy Peanut Butter

stc1993 said:

I eat Peter Pan honey roast.  Once you eat it you'll never eat regular pb again.

I love the honey roasted, it is a creamy peanut butter. 

fins4me

Crunchy Peanut Butter

I prefer crunchy but have a plate of dates stuffed with either creamy peanut butter,  cream cheese or Nutella as I get ready for the Tennessee  vs Kansas basketball game later this evening. 

Resinhead

:facepalm

JustDave

Creamy Peanut Butter

stc1993 said:

I eat Peter Pan honey roast.  Once you eat it you'll never eat regular pb again.

Once my wife got that honey roasted crap by mistake and made me some PB crackers with it. After the first bite I  told her something was wrong. Ended up tossing the rest of that Jar because no one in my family liked it. Back to regular creamy PB we went. 

mindyabiness

Peanuts are truly a gift.
One of the original G.M.O. plant species from Latin America along with corn (modified the hard way)…..they have quickly become one of the most prolifically cultivated legumes in the world.

I have a jar of creamy in my pantry at the moment. I think choosing the correct brand is more important than the type. if It's good.... creamy or crunchy is a side note.

fins4me said:

I prefer crunchy but have a plate of dates stuffed with either creamy peanut butter,  cream cheese or Nutella as I get ready for the Tennessee  vs Kansas basketball game later this evening. 

What kind of dates?

AC Man

Crunchy Peanut Butter

Crunchy all the way.......I agree with creamy as a child. Once grown no comparison. 

mindyabiness

AC Man said:

Crunchy all the way.......I agree with creamy as a child. Once grown no comparison. 

Ah...I get it.

Real men choose crunchy......

Gardawg

It's like buying shoes with the socks already in them.

mplspug

Creamy Peanut Butter

Skippy or Jiff Natural all the way.  

As a kid I hated anything lumpy.  Hated lumpy peanut butter, lumpy mashed potatoes, cookies with nuts....

jcbcpa

Creamy Peanut Butter

Jiff Natural. Usually eat it in my oatmeal for breakfast. 

swampwalker

No preference - I love peanut butter! It travels well and compliments a lot fruits. About once a week I have a pb&j with fritos for lunch or when in the woods.

hatcity

Creamy Peanut Butter

creamy, Skippy. end of discussion

AC Man

Crunchy Peanut Butter

I don't usually
argue, but I can't imagine smooth over crunchy. It's a no brainer. Lol.

Resinhead

Creamy is easier for the dog lovers to get...

Nevermind

mindyabiness

Freudian slip?

Resinhead

Nope. I'm an extra crunchy guy.

You guys enjoy the dogs and creamy.

Mango Man

Resinhead said:

:facepalm

LOL

Gary S

I didn't vote because I like them both. As far as brands, I can't taste a difference. Store brand is fine with me.

cadman

Creamy Peanut Butter

Resinhead said:

Nope. I'm an extra crunchy guy.

You guys enjoy the dogs and creamy.

You are the only one who mentioned feeding your dog Peanut butter. 

Florida Bullfrog

Crunchy Peanut Butter

Crunchy.

cadman

Creamy Peanut Butter

It appears creamy is the winner, 

AC Man

Crunchy Peanut Butter

Lol. I dont think I ate creamy since i was 10 years old. Crunchy is 10 times better unless you are using it in othe recipes.. 

Peanut butter and jelly/ peanut butter and bsnana.... Crunchy all the way baby..

stc1993

Peanut butter on apples is good too.

restlessnative

If cyclist were here he would tell you all how much rat poo is in peanut butter and then virtue signal about it. As to the poll I don’t really eat much so whatever the wife has in the pantry on the occasion I dip some carrots or celery in it for a snack.

Flash

Crunchy Peanut Butter

Crunchy for us.

dave44

Crunchy Peanut Butter

cadman said:

It appears creamy is the winner, 

You can’t stop counting votes now. I’ve found a box of provisional ballots on the beach, Every vote must count.