Skip to main content
Home Off Topic

When did hand brake change to

GrizGriz Posts: 9,951 Admin
Parking brake, foot brake and now in some cars electronic and sets itself? What do you do f you lose your brakes and have not a lever or pedal? I've always liked a proper hand set emergency brake and detested the foot set. The electronic is absurd.
The early bird may get the worm, but the Second Mouse gets the cheese. SW

:Griz
«1

Replies

  • JKPJKP Posts: 3,211 Captain
    It's better than folks who think parking lights are "running" lights.
  • HeatwaveHeatwave Posts: 1,997 Captain
    Griz wrote: »
    Parking brake, foot brake and now in some cars electronic and sets itself? What do you do f you lose your brakes and have not a lever or pedal? I've always liked a proper hand set emergency brake and detested the foot set. The electronic is absurd.

    I agree, it is now past human and all about the $$$$$$$$$$$$ It fails, call and get tow, then shop (only their shop).... Just like self driving, I can see assist on highway, or even a sleep monitor, safety setup... Sad how they are taking what makes better humans away from all of us. I wont let my kid get a NAV. system.. I want her to learn her way around, not count on a nav to tell her everything...
  • ResinheadResinhead Posts: 10,987 AG
    Did the weekly Friday moderator meeting really approve this as a post positive topic?
  • SLSSLS Posts: 181 Deckhand
    Griz wrote: »
    I've always liked a proper hand set emergency brake and detested the foot set. The electronic is absurd.

    Ok I don't know anything about an electronic brake, and maybe you're right, maybe it's a bad idea, "but" your comment sounds like, I assume, hundreds off comments in the past to new technology.

    Who needs automatic transmission, fuel injectors, power windows, power steering, power brakes, anti lock brakes, (and now) cameras, auto braking, lane change warnings, etc., etc..

    I assume lots of time and money went into R&D on this issue ad was deamed to be a good idea.
  • jad1097jad1097 Posts: 9,611 Admiral
    they have been around for 15 years or so
  • AC ManAC Man Posts: 7,304 Admiral
    Griz wrote: »
    Parking brake, foot brake and now in some cars electronic and sets itself? What do you do f you lose your brakes and have not a lever or pedal? I've always liked a proper hand set emergency brake and detested the foot set. The electronic is absurd.

    In my mind parking brakes are for manual transmission safety. Unless you are my youngest son who broke out the wife's John Cooper Works Mini Cooper and used it as a hand brake to pivot corners and flat spot $1500 worth of tires. Funny now, not at the time.
  • jad1097jad1097 Posts: 9,611 Admiral
    AC Man wrote: »
    In my mind parking brakes are for manual transmission safety. Unless you are my youngest son who broke out the wife's John Cooper Works Mini Cooper and used it as a hand brake to pivot corners and flat spot $1500 worth of tires. Funny now, not at the time.


    Hand brakes can be fun ;)
  • GardawgGardawg Posts: 16,720 AG
    electric brakes weigh less than the manual setup

    that's the impetus for them
    "Forgiveness is a strange thing. It can be sometimes easier to forgive our enemies than our friends. It can be hardest of all to forgive people we love." Fred Rogers  
  • Team SabatageTeam Sabatage Posts: 13,014 AG
    Griz wrote: »
    Parking brake, foot brake and now in some cars electronic and sets itself? What do you do f you lose your brakes and have not a lever or pedal? I've always liked a proper hand set emergency brake and detested the foot set. The electronic is absurd.

    Crash and burn, baby, crash and burn...
    Strap me in, tie me down and roll me a bone, I'm getting on an airplane and I'm flying home...
  • HeatwaveHeatwave Posts: 1,997 Captain
    SLS wrote: »
    Ok I don't know anything about an electronic brake, and maybe you're right, maybe it's a bad idea, "but" your comment sounds like, I assume, hundreds off comments in the past to new technology.

    Who needs automatic transmission, fuel injectors, power windows, power steering, power brakes, anti lock brakes, (and now) cameras, auto braking, lane change warnings, etc., etc..

    I assume lots of time and money went into R&D on this issue ad was deamed to be a good idea.

    At what point does MAKING more money become Absurd ? Lots of things have had R&D spent on it and failed, like the Electric Car. That thing was awesome, but GM bought out the patent on the Battery, then sold it to big oil who had the cars crushed and buried in the desert. The things listed in your "who needs" were all good ideas and very helpful. At one point or another, it ends (better product) and common sense has to take hold. The fact that it was deemed a good idea has to do with MONEY only, nothing else was considered, and wont be until someone dies, by then the engineers and people in charge will be gone and not responsible for the outcome.
    Just look at VW issue and the setup with milage. You can bet those that designed the program were forced to or be fired, they had a choice and only now does that choice matter. Had they raised a flag when it was happening they would have been labeled a snitch or a nut job. You just cant win at the bottom of the ladder these days.
  • CountryBumpkinCountryBumpkin Posts: 1,893 Captain
    I have to get on the :bandwagon with the it's all about making them money or lessening their liability.

    If it was about what we might want or need..........vehicles would have self tinting windows as standard equipment by now.:wink
  • dannosdoormatsdannosdoormats Posts: 181 Deckhand
    I just laid out $150.00 to tint my windows on a 2016 Honda Accord--extra.
  • Wildcard2950Wildcard2950 Posts: 79 Deckhand
    My wife's car has this and I like the auto feature. With that being said probably 50% of parking brakes with the manual level don't work from never being used.

    She was driving the other day and noticed an amber light came on the dash while she was stopped at the light. The light appeared to be traction control. I looked into it and it is roll control. if you depress the brake again after your are stopped it will turn on and hold the card for 2 seconds to prevent you from rolling on a hill.
  • gandrfabgandrfab Posts: 21,646 AG
    I'd type it out but you keep a worthless mod that should go.
  • GrizGriz Posts: 9,951 Admin
    Should the hydraulics on your car fail how would you stop it other than down shifting or coasting. They used be called emergency brakes for a reason. I always use mine when I park and was required to use one once when I did lose the brakes on my car.
    The early bird may get the worm, but the Second Mouse gets the cheese. SW

    :Griz
  • cadmancadman Posts: 43,623 AG
    Griz wrote: »
    Parking brake, foot brake and now in some cars electronic and sets itself? What do you do f you lose your brakes and have not a lever or pedal? I've always liked a proper hand set emergency brake and detested the foot set. The electronic is absurd.

    When you had drum brakes where the pad swiveled, you could use a cable linked to an emergency brake to stop the car. The name hand break came out later on when the foot pedal emergency brake moved to a center mounted hand brake in cars with bucket seats.

    When cars moved to all disk brakes for safety reasons, it is not possible to use a manual cable to pull the hand brake. The parking brake is now part of the hydraulic system. If the hydraulics fail, the parking brake ain't going to do any good.

    BTW, have you ever used the old cable emergency brake to stop you if your brakes failed? I did once, it doesn't work that well since the cable is only activating the rear wheel brakes. Takes about twice as long to stop.

    Former Mini Mart Magnate

    I am just here for my amusement. 

  • GrizGriz Posts: 9,951 Admin
    cadman wrote: »
    When you had drum brakes where the pad swiveled, you could use a cable linked to an emergency brake to stop the car. The name hand break came out later on when the foot pedal emergency brake moved to a center mounted hand brake in cars with bucket seats.

    When cars moved to all disk brakes for safety reasons, it is not possible to use a manual cable to pull the hand brake. The parking brake is now part of the hydraulic system. If the hydraulics fail, the parking brake ain't going to do any good.

    BTW, have you ever used the old cable emergency brake to stop you if your brakes failed? I did once, it doesn't work that well since the cable is only activating the rear wheel brakes. Takes about twice as long to stop.

    Not correct. I have a cable on both my Jeep and Mini Cooper. One controls a dedicated parking brake caliper and on the rear rotor and the other there is internal drum brakes in the rear rotor.
    The early bird may get the worm, but the Second Mouse gets the cheese. SW

    :Griz
  • cadmancadman Posts: 43,623 AG
    Griz wrote: »
    Not correct. I have a cable on both my Jeep and Mini Cooper. One controls a dedicated parking brake caliper and on the rear rotor and the other there is internal drum brakes in the rear rotor.

    Most new cars are four wheel disk. What year are your vehicles and which one still uses drum brakes?

    Former Mini Mart Magnate

    I am just here for my amusement. 

  • Wildcard2950Wildcard2950 Posts: 79 Deckhand
    Griz wrote: »
    Should the hydraulics on your car fail how would you stop it other than down shifting or coasting. They used be called emergency brakes for a reason. I always use mine when I park and was required to use one once when I did lose the brakes on my car.

    I can check, but I believe you press the button the active the E-brake. I thought I read it's still a mechanical braking system only uses a solenoid to activate it. There a level in the trunk to release it if it malfunctions.
  • GrizGriz Posts: 9,951 Admin
    cadman wrote: »
    Most new cars are four wheel disk. What year are your vehicles and which one still uses drum brakes?

    They're both four wheel disc. The Jeep has an interior shoe on the rear the rotor and the Mini has a dedicated caliper for the emergency brake.
    The early bird may get the worm, but the Second Mouse gets the cheese. SW

    :Griz
  • GrizGriz Posts: 9,951 Admin
    I can check, but I believe you press the button the active the E-brake. I thought I read it's still a mechanical braking system only uses a solenoid to activate it. There a level in the trunk to release it if it malfunctions.

    That may be.
    The early bird may get the worm, but the Second Mouse gets the cheese. SW

    :Griz
  • PotholePothole Posts: 1,373 Officer
    cadman wrote: »
    Most new cars are four wheel disk. What year are your vehicles and which one still uses drum brakes?

    Even with 4 wheel disk, most, not all, still have a cable e-brake. Look it up. I'm sure your google finger is working.
  • cadmancadman Posts: 43,623 AG
    Pothole wrote: »
    Even with 4 wheel disk, most, not all, still have a cable e-brake. Look it up. I'm sure your google finger is working.

    I will check my truck. I made a misassumption. I want to see how a cable works on disk brakes.

    Former Mini Mart Magnate

    I am just here for my amusement. 

  • M.MagisM.Magis Posts: 204 Deckhand
    cadman wrote: »
    I will check my truck. I made a misassumption. I want to see how a cable works on disk brakes.

    Many (or most) have both. Normal brakes are disk, but the parking brake is drum. Both work on the same rotor, the drum brake just uses the ID.
  • Wildcard2950Wildcard2950 Posts: 79 Deckhand
    My Honda Accord's rear brake piston turns out when the e-brake is applied. On my Pilot and Suburban they use the inside of the rotor as a drum and have another set of shoes.
  • stc1993stc1993 Posts: 10,610 AG
    I put new rotors & disk pads on my Avalanche this past weekend & it has the little drum e-brakes on the inside of the disk rotor they're only about an 1" - 1 1/8" wide. I've got to go back & change them also, they are wore out. I can probably count on one hand all the times i've used the e-brakes. How did they get wore out puzzles me.

    I might just take them to the shop this time. I don't feel like going thru that again. It's hell getting old.
  • surfmansurfman Posts: 6,017 Admiral
    Heck people driving cars today don't even know what to do when the gas pedal sticks, they just call 911 and just hold on and scream, kind of funny though really.
    Tight Lines, Steve
    My posts are my opinion only.

    Be thankful we're not getting all the government we're paying for.  Will Rogers
  • NSB PhotogNSB Photog Posts: 542 Officer
    How is it that nobody has asked for a pic of Griz in a Mini Cooper? :shrug
  • PolarPolar Posts: 22,492 AG
    NSB Photog wrote: »
    How is it that nobody has asked for a pic of Griz in a Mini Cooper? :shrug

    I wanted to, so badly but Im being nice today
  • conquistadorconquistador Posts: 223 Deckhand
    Heatwave wrote: »
    I agree, it is now past human and all about the $$$$$$$$$$$$ It fails, call and get tow, then shop (only their shop).... Just like self driving, I can see assist on highway, or even a sleep monitor, safety setup... Sad how they are taking what makes better humans away from all of us. I wont let my kid get a NAV. system.. I want her to learn her way around, not count on a nav to tell her everything...

    With most folks glued to their cell phones, I'm looking forward to self driving cars, less people to worry about in S. Fla.
    2005 29' Ocean Runner w/Twin 200hp
    1996 24' CC w/300 Yamaha - Sold
Sign In or Register to comment.
Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

Preview This Month's Issue

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Florida Sportsman App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Florida Sportsman stories delivered right to your inbox.

Advertisement

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Florida Sportsman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now