FSU's Sean Maguire

2amigo

Thought and stated he should have started from Day 1 and definitely by game 4. Golson has not shown ANYTHING special and no leadership. Maguire could not have done any worse than Golson has throughout the season. Proof is in today's game. I knew this yet Jimbo and other Nole faithful did not.

Bobber

Agreed - so who's Dabo gonna prep for?

on_the_rocks

Problem.
Jimbo promised Goldon the job.

Flash

Isn't he just a Jr.? Surprised he does not take a transfer if Jimbo stays with Golson. He seems like a dang good QB.

navigator2

2amigo wrote: »

Thought and stated he should have started from Day 1 and definitely by game 4. Golson has not shown ANYTHING special and no leadership. Maguire could not have done any worse than Golson has throughout the season. Proof is in today's game. I knew this yet Jimbo and other Nole faithful did not.

I hate to say this but Dumbo screwed the pooch once again starting the loser from Notre Dame. That's what Dumbo does though, and why we love him. McGuire actually looks competent. Golson couldn't start for UM.

The MelMan

I think there must be some resentment among the receivers and line that McGuire isn't playing.........could explain their sorry play previous and their turnaround today. Adds a little pressure to the defensive prep by Clemson..............

JaxNole

2amigo wrote: »

Thought and stated he should have started from Day 1 and definitely by game 4. Golson has not shown ANYTHING special and no leadership. Maguire could not have done any worse than Golson has throughout the season. Proof is in today's game. I knew this yet Jimbo and other Nole faithful did not.

:rolleyes

JKP

Offensive line played poorly, especially 55.

At least Maguire can throw the deep ball. One game against lowly Syracuse doesn't tell a complete story but he did look solid.

2amigo

JaxNole wrote: »

:rolleyes

Jax, I don't need to but you can go back to other threads where I have stated that. Noles are a lot quieter this year now that Gata is doing well and have a bright future. :rotflmao

2amigo

JKP wrote: »

Offensive line played poorly, especially 55.

At least Maguire can throw the deep ball. One game against lowly Syracuse doesn't tell a complete story but he did look solid.

All the games Golson played against ALL lowly opponents he never looked good. If it wasn't for Cook there would be more losses. Syracuse is not that any different than the rest of the competition the Noles have played.

JaxNole

2amigo wrote: »

Jax, I don't need to but you can go back to other threads where I have stated that. Noles are a lot quieter this year now that Gata is doing well and have a bright future. :rotflmao

Then tell us all why in the hell are you not coaching then? SM has looked less than average up until this game to the staff, the fans, and everyone who has eyes. I am happy he did well, but you get absolutely zero credit no matter what you said and when.

2amigo

JaxNole wrote: »

Then tell us all why in the hell are you not coaching then? SM has looked less than average up until this game to the staff, the fans, and everyone who has eyes. I am happy he did well, but you get absolutely zero credit no matter what you said and when.

He mad! Relax Jax. We were 4-8 2 years ago and Gator fans here kept on truckin'. Be happy. It's been a good run and should be better with Maguire. He had 2 days of prep last year and beat a decent Clemson team. Some mistakes but overall did good in the end when it counted. Golson was BENCHED ( talking about average) at an over rated ND. They didn't want him, why should the Noles? Stick with the guys who came there from high school and bled garnet and gold. Not some waste of time who couldn't make it at his own school. If you have been to a game you would see that there was no leadership coming from Golson on the sideline. Maguire may not be the greatest but the team will respond to him from a chemistry standpoint. Proof is on this past game. By the way, all of of us have made calls on a team that were correct that the coaches or management f'ed up on. Do you think you should be coaching because you thought Muschamp sucked as a head coach overall like everybody else in the nation ? No, but you knew better . Right?

P.S. I know you chimed in early in the season when Res and I betted. We still on?

ZimmerNole

navigator2 wrote: »

I hate to say this but Dumbo screwed the pooch once again starting the loser from Notre Dame. That's what Dumbo does though, and why we love him. McGuire actually looks competent. Golson couldn't start for UM.

Screwed the pooch again? What has Jimbo done wrong?

These comments make me laugh.

JaxNole

2amigo wrote: »

He mad! Relax Jax. We were 4-8 2 years ago and Gator fans here kept on truckin'. Be happy. It's been a good run and should be better with Maguire. He had 2 days of prep last year and beat a decent Clemson team. Some mistakes but overall did good in the end when it counted. Golson was BENCHED ( talking about average) at an over rated ND. They didn't want him, why should the Noles? Stick with the guys who came there from high school and bled garnet and gold. Not some waste of time who couldn't make it at his own school. If you have been to a game you would see that there was no leadership coming from Golson on the sideline. Maguire may not be the greatest but the team will respond to him from a chemistry standpoint. Proof is on this past game. By the way, all of of us have made calls on a team that were correct that the coaches or management f'ed up on. Do you think you should be coaching because you thought Muschamp sucked as a head coach overall like everybody else in the nation ? No, but you knew better . Right?

P.S. I know you chimed in early in the season when Res and I betted. We still on?

Far from mad. I just have the common sense to trust a proven coach who sees players a lot more than fans. Yes, we are still on. And for the record, I think the Gata should have given Muschamp a lifetime contract.

dpdash

Was at the Cuse game and I was impressed with Maguire, very nice touch on long balls, the O line gave him all day to throw, I say play him vs Clemson

nole76

dpdash wrote: »

Was at the Cuse game and I was impressed with Maguire, very nice touch on long balls, the O line gave him all day to throw, I say play him vs Clemson

Or at least don't announce a starter 'til an hour before the game.

BayGator

Syracuse looked like a high school team trying to compete Saturday. I doubt it will be that easy for Sean MaguireEverett Golson this weekend.

navigator2

ZimmerNole wrote: »

Screwed the pooch again? What has Jimbo done wrong?

These comments make me laugh.

G-O-L-S-O-N

I thought you might actually watch your own team's games. Golson looks like crap even with Cook in the game. :grin

MARLIN44

navigator2 wrote: »

G-O-L-S-O-N

I thought you might actually watch your own team's games. Golson looks like crap even with Cook in the game. :grin

Best screen passer in the game...

ZimmerNole

He took a chance on a 5th year senior QB who has played in big time games.

I'd rather see Golson come to FSU for the P-O-T-E-N-T-I-A-L he could've had, rather than never take a stab at it at all.

Clemson has to prep fro 2 totally different QBs and two totally different RBs.

Makomenuts

Maquire took all 1st team reps at practice yesterday if that is an indication of what will be coming this weekend. He looked pretty good with the deep ball, Cambell dropped a would be 60+ yard td pass in the 2nd half.

Madbeach

I'm surprised we haven't seen more of Campbell. Is he just grasping the playbook slow?

I hope Smag starts. Run Patrick and Cook so they have to stack the box to open throwing windows.

JaxNole

Madbeach wrote: »

I'm surprised we haven't seen more of Campbell. Is he just grasping the playbook slow?

I hope Smag starts. Run Patrick and Cook so they have to stack the box to open throwing windows.

George is raw. Think KB with more speed. It is taking him a while to turn into what he can be, but he will be special. And can you imagine Patrick and Cook in the Pro-set with single tight? Can't wait!

ZimmerNole

Next year....holy jesus

Cooks last year, better OL, Patrick 2nd year, Sweat and Derwin 2nd year, tons of talent at WR and the secondary.

We could be very, very good next year.

Makomenuts

I will be arriving in Clemson, SC Friday afternoon about 4 pm. Sounds like we have a good amount of rain that will be coming through at kick off. Fields going to get sloppy probably going to see a lot of running plays from both sides. Still want to see Sean at qb though.

2amigo

Maguire at least hypes up this otherwise flat offense. I posted positive about this kid and how it changes the demeanor of your offense and Jax about tore my head off. :grin

navigator2

2amigo wrote: »

Maguire at least hypes up this otherwise flat offense. I posted positive about this kid and how it changes the demeanor of your offense and Jax about tore my head off. :grin

That was kind of my point earlier. Jim Dummy is Mark Richt Jr. Tipping my glass to Golson and hoping he starts the rest of the year.:rotflmao

ZimmerNole

2amigo wrote: »

Maguire at least hypes up this otherwise flat offense. I posted positive about this kid and how it changes the demeanor of your offense and Jax about tore my head off. :grin

I agree 100%

When Campbell dropped an easy 60yd TD what did SMAG do? He ran over to him and shouted at him.

1. Golson can't make that throw
2. Golson would have whined to Jimbo
3. Golson doesn't grab anyone by the facemask and pump them up.
4. Jimbo would have never called the play....because Golson has a noodle arm.
5. Yes, It was CUSE.

However, I like the element of the vertical passing attack. Everyone props up Golsons mobility (and I did at the beginning of the season and 2 games in) but I don't think his perceived mobility is more valuable than Smag's arm. Granted, the propensity for Smag making a mistake is much higher than Golson, but it's also because of the game flow and the way Jimbo calls the screens/westcoast/dink-dunk offense when EG6 is at the helm. We never would have aired it out EVEN VERSUS CUSE with EG6 under center.

I felt bad for SMag at the beginning of the year when we brought in EG6. Is he a world beater? No, but he committed to Jimbo/FSU, learned the system, sat behind the best QB to ever wear Garnet and Gold and didn't transfer the way Coker/Trickett and John Franklin III did. The kid is a NOLE through and through, and I believe he has a better grasp on the system, the playbook and that locker room as he has been around those guys for 3 years, not just 3 months.

I'd be happier with a loss at the hands of Smag, than a loss at the hands of Golson. If I see another pass thrown at a WR's feet a la Tebow I'll lose my mind.

I say we win vs GT with Smag on the field, just saying.

We took a chance on Golson, it could've paid off....but it didn't IMHO. Let's let Smag get the reps as he SHOULD be the starter next season or at least battle it out with Francois, another kid who bleeds garnet and gold.

#RecencyBias LOL

navigator2 wrote: »

That was kind of my point earlier. Jim Dummy is Mark Richt Jr. Tipping my glass to Golson and hoping he starts the rest of the year.:rotflmao

You're way off base dude, I really don't understand your vitriol for Jimbo. Even the level headed Gata fans on here will admit he is one of the top 5-7 coaches in CFB. He has already done more as HC then Richt has in half the time. Kiss the ring!

He took a chance, it could've paid off immensely. I'd rather see us go after Golson/Braxton Miller than not

navigator2

ZimmerNole wrote: »

I agree 100%

When Campbell dropped an easy 60yd TD what did SMAG do? He ran over to him and shouted at him.

1. Golson can't make that throw
2. Golson would have whined to Jimbo
3. Golson doesn't grab anyone by the facemask and pump them up.
4. Jimbo would have never called the play....because Golson has a noodle arm.
5. Yes, It was CUSE.

However, I like the element of the vertical passing attack. Everyone props up Golsons mobility (and I did at the beginning of the season and 2 games in) but I don't think his perceived mobility is more valuable than Smag's arm. Granted, the propensity for Smag making a mistake is much higher than Golson, but it's also because of the game flow and the way Jimbo calls the screens/westcoast/dink-dunk offense when EG6 is at the helm. We never would have aired it out EVEN VERSUS CUSE with EG6 under center.

I felt bad for SMag at the beginning of the year when we brought in EG6. Is he a world beater? No, but he committed to Jimbo/FSU, learned the system, sat behind the best QB to ever wear Garnet and Gold and didn't transfer the way Coker/Trickett and John Franklin III did. The kid is a NOLE through and through, and I believe he has a better grasp on the system, the playbook and that locker room as he has been around those guys for 3 years, not just 3 months.

I'd be happier with a loss at the hands of Smag, than a loss at the hands of Golson. If I see another pass thrown at a WR's feet a la Tebow I'll lose my mind.

I say we win vs GT with Smag on the field, just saying.

We took a chance on Golson, it could've paid off....but it didn't IMHO. Let's let Smag get the reps as he SHOULD be the starter next season or at least battle it out with Francois, another kid who bleeds garnet and gold.

#RecencyBias LOL



You're way off base dude, I really don't understand your vitriol for Jimbo. Even the level headed Gata fans on here will admit he is one of the top 5-7 coaches in CFB. He has already done more as HC then Richt has in half the time. Kiss the ring!

He took a chance, it could've paid off immensely. I'd rather see us go after Golson/Braxton Miller than not

Ponder this. If Richt gets the ax, I hope Dumbo becomes a mutt.............and I hate UGA wayyyyyyyyyyyy more than the nulls.:rotflmao

ZimmerNole

LOL.

If Jimbo went to UGA, y'all would be screwed.

2amigo

I thought this should be brought back up top. Why did Jimbo start Golson? Because Maguire didn't play that great against Clemson who is arguably the best team in the nation? Golson would have been embarrassed by Clemson. Probably 4 pics. Jax, are you going to tell me again Jimbo knows more than me about who should start? :grin.