Skip to main content
Home Off Topic

College admissions consultant... Did you use one for your kid ? Help !

HeatwaveHeatwave Posts: 1,997 Captain
There is just so much information now, offers, tests, etc. Neither of us went to a major college, the process is new to us and we are, hate to say it, lost and overwhelmed. We want to offer her the best education we can. Yet affraid we will miss something this year or next on the runup to chosing, costs, grants, etc...

The consultant business is big now. We are going to give it a try. Look for the best bang for the buck. Someone here has to hae a good and or bad story.

On top of that, she is still a little unsure of what she wants to do... Been headed towards a PA... I think there will be lots of jobs in that field, even for a PA. I also think hospitals and Private practice doctors will have that job reduced down to a 50K a year job as they increase their own pay to 750K from 400K.

Any help would be greatly appriciated, more than you will even know...
«1

Replies

  • hotrailshotrails Posts: 440 Deckhand
    Probably many others went through same ordeal

    We went to many college nights,expo's at schools ,gathered lot of information Good Bad, there is many Grants//scholarship that go unused each year look hard at Pell Grants, Daughter did not even apply yet was give scholarship by Bank which we did not use.

    A great Book is called ""Don't Miss out"" I do not think I would hire or such as consultant yet until you have reached end of rope doing some digging spend few hours here there will keep every one up to speed one may find a point others overlooked

    I would have to ask Daughter how ever she worked at some cafeteria Campus) for meals few bucks pocket money, so schools have programs such as this, as I dam sure could not afford her going to Marquette on Chief in Navy pay

    Not going to be an easy task but doable also share with other families in same situation, Oh she also asked her teaches about their school about financial aid packages and what better place to get info right from Alumni

    Good Luck
  • fish_stixfish_stix Posts: 1,395 Officer
    If she's unsure of what she wants out of an education then let her attend a Community college until she decides. Far less money and she can live at home. She can load up on required coursework and be miles ahead when she gets to a 4 year college. My granddaughter is in the same boat but went to an expensive private college for her 1st year. Big mistake! Now she owes lots of money for loans, still has no clue of a direction and is currently enrolled in the local community college, where she should have gone in the first place.
  • fishknutfishknut Posts: 3,921 Captain
    Heatwave wrote: »
    There is just so much information now, offers, tests, etc. Neither of us went to a major college, the process is new to us and we are, hate to say it, lost and overwhelmed. We want to offer her the best education we can. Yet affraid we will miss something this year or next on the runup to chosing, costs, grants, etc...

    The consultant business is big now. We are going to give it a try. Look for the best bang for the buck. Someone here has to hae a good and or bad story.

    On top of that, she is still a little unsure of what she wants to do... Been headed towards a PA... I think there will be lots of jobs in that field, even for a PA. I also think hospitals and Private practice doctors will have that job reduced down to a 50K a year job as they increase their own pay to 750K from 400K.

    Any help would be greatly appriciated, more than you will even know...


    I went to a seminar put on by one of those consultants, it seemed very expensive for what they offered. The bad thing is they wont say what they can do for you until you sit down with them and start the process. I understand everyone has different circumstances, but it seemed like he could have at least narrowed it down. I might check out that book that was recommended.
    Fail to plan, plan to fail.......
  • ParkerboyParkerboy Posts: 7,045 Admiral
    I also advocate Community College for the first two years although many kids want to get away from home and be on their own. I don't think most 18 year olds are mature enough to handle them selves at a large university which leads to problems such as binge drinking, **** of you girls etc. Before someone counters with 18 year old's being in the military, those kids are under scrunity and direction nearly 24 hours per day.

    After 2 years of community college they can transfer to a university and when they graduate their degree will be no different than the students who spent their entire time at the university.

    Sent from my KFJWA using Tapatalk
    Deo Vindice
  • tandtand Posts: 52 Greenhorn
    Heatwave wrote: »
    There is just so much information now, offers, tests, etc. Neither of us went to a major college, the process is new to us and we are, hate to say it, lost and overwhelmed. We want to offer her the best education we can. Yet affraid we will miss something this year or next on the runup to chosing, costs, grants, etc...

    The consultant business is big now. We are going to give it a try. Look for the best bang for the buck. Someone here has to hae a good and or bad story.

    On top of that, she is still a little unsure of what she wants to do... Been headed towards a PA... I think there will be lots of jobs in that field, even for a PA. I also think hospitals and Private practice doctors will have that job reduced down to a 50K a year job as they increase their own pay to 750K from 400K.

    Any help would be greatly appriciated, more than you will even know...

    You think a DR makes 400k...ha...maybe in the old day. Dr'a graduation now are happy to make their loan payments and drive a Camry.

    Nothing wrong with being a PA either. I know lots of docs and a few PAs. Both like their jobs but until you are through 2-3 years of college you never know. Good luck to your daughter!
  • hotrailshotrails Posts: 440 Deckhand
    Agree 100% most 18 year old not ready for major college they do not have regimentation nor time management skills down (Yet) Our Daughter had skipped Grade went off to Major college in August and she had turned 17 in April same year, she lasted 1 1/2year,just was not ready and was burned out Joined Navy spent 4 years (2 years NAS Oceana 2 years NAS P Cola) AZ 2, and she was then ready, knew what she wanted had set a Goal went for it, made it, and went on an obtained MS

    Seeing more and more PA at VA hospital and most walk in clinics locally have a couple of staff PA..

    I cant buy off on consultant, afraid they will paint a pretty visual picture and not harsh reality explaining pit falls and obstacles in way of attaining goal
  • Fish HaidFish Haid Posts: 8,417 Admiral
    Don't be fooled into thinking that paying more for a "good" school is automatically an advantage for a job with more money later.

    I would rather hire a bright kid who excelled in a lesser school than a kid who did average in a "good" school.
    23895.gif
  • Fishin_bluesFishin_blues Posts: 36 Deckhand
    The main concern about doing 2 year community college is that the average community college it taught at a lower level than a typical 4 year school. My oldest went this route and made almost straight A's while goofing off the whole time. He started is 3rd year with the same mindset and killed his gpa the first semester, finding it significantly harder and he actually couldn't get by without studying. Buckled down the rest of the time but didn't graduate with honors simply due to that one semester.
  • MelbourneMarkMelbourneMark Posts: 3,843 Captain
    Good for you that you are doing the research on this. College can be VERY expensive. It sounds like your daughter has an idea of what she wants to do. I hope that you can get her in touch with some people in the field, and maybe she can ask questions or even follow them around some.
    I agree that community college can be cheaper and easier to get the basic required classes out of the way. I would urge you to try to limit that amount of student loans if you can. If she continues with the med school track, the loans can easily be >$100k.

    My wife is getting her PHD in Biology, and many of her classmates have 10s of thousands even 100k in student loan debt. Some chose to go to schools out of state. Sometimes, that is necessary for some career tracts, but usually you can at least get the 4yr degree in state which is cheaper. With a lot of hard work, some luck, some students can get grants/fellowships which will pay for school, and/or even provide a salary during school. Your daughter can look these up and apply for them. (national science foundation, national institute of health etc..)
  • cprcpr Posts: 9,299 Admiral
    First off I totally agree on the CC idea. It's cheap and college 101 credits are just that transferable basic credits at a cheap price. My youngest paid $1550.00 for 15 credits his first semester while living at home and working.

    As for the consultant, my issue is that the the student not the parents should learn and work the system. That is part of the learning process. If they can figure out and deal with the adult world, then they are ready, otherwise they might need more seasoning.
    "The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time, and still retain the ability to function." F. Scott Fitzgerald

    "Prediction is very difficult, especially if it's about the future." Niels Bohr
  • MRichardsonMRichardson Posts: 10,466 AG
    College consultant?
    Jesus what has it come to?
    Pick a university.
    Pick a program.
    Excel in said program.
    Mix with corporate sponsors/alumni.
    Work with the career dept of the school.
    Intern.

    Knowing what to do is easy, you don't need a consultant for that.
    I have never seen live bones, but I know that they are often used by rich people to decorate the interior.
  • PilchardPilchard Posts: 1,373 Officer
    Check out Hobsons/naviance. They have a great college and carrier readiness platform that about 35% of k-12 schools use nationwide. They also help colleges attract and retain students that are the right fit for a given university/program.

    If your child doesn't have access to this via their current school, you may be able to contact them directly for some data-driven insight based on your child's performance and interests.

    Disclaimer- I have no ties to the company just have a unique view of this market because of my career.
  • FishInFLFishInFL Posts: 2,222 Captain
    How do they help?

    Get good grades, good SAT scores, referrals from teacher, and apply. You get in some and not others, so choose your fav.
  • jsrodguy1jsrodguy1 Posts: 558 Officer
    Don't waste your hard earned money on some consultants. Do your own homework, my daughters high school had plenty of resources for us to use to make wise choices. How much more information do you need with the internet at your finger tips? don't take the easy way out.
    Great Grades, Bright Futures, Pre-Paid Tuition, Great ACT Scores all lead up to being accepted to a great state school!
  • CyclistCyclist Posts: 23,340 AG
    Parkerboy wrote: »
    I also advocate Community College for the first two years although many kids want to get away from home and be on their own. I don't think most 18 year olds are mature enough to handle them selves at a large university which leads to problems such as binge drinking, **** of you girls etc. Before someone counters with 18 year old's being in the military, those kids are under scrunity and direction nearly 24 hours per day.

    After 2 years of community college they can transfer to a university and when they graduate their degree will be no different than the students who spent their entire time at the university.

    Sent from my KFJWA using Tapatalk

    For most kids, I think you guys are correct.
  • HeatwaveHeatwave Posts: 1,997 Captain
    College consultant?
    Jesus what has it come to?
    Pick a university.
    Pick a program.
    Excel in said program.
    Mix with corporate sponsors/alumni.
    Work with the career dept of the school.
    Intern.

    Knowing what to do is easy, you don't need a consultant for that.


    Sorry, just getting back to this.. As far as the CC goes, she will have a two year degree before she is out of high school from IRCC.. That is the good, the bad is that she only does anything of this because we push. She in NOT leading the way here. Her mother and I were both go getters, so to speak, but did so only after learning high school was not enough. We did not know each other then of course.

    Anyway, back to KID.. Great kid, and will do anything we ask, but that is it. Not much on the social side for getting out with others, making contacts, etc. That could have a lot to do with both parents working from home and making good money. She see's it as easy...

    Neither of us have any experience with making sure she gets all the money she can. I would think that there is something that offers that... No ?

    I think it would be best for her to learn this process on her own. With us just to guide a little, like others wrote, not really ready for big school. I know, if not now, it will never happen as I can see her NOT fighting hard for what she wants. I for one won't lay out each thing for her, somethings she needs to learn. On the other hand, my wife will say when frustrated watching our girl struggle with something, here, let me do it. THen say, see, that is how it is done. Bad bad experience for a kid and I keep stating such. She won't listen and wants to bring her up much slower than I do. It could be something as simple as cleaning the car. In place of working with her, she would rather tell her howe to do it, then complain when it isn't correct. I get frustrated with that stuff because I know spending time with her is much better.

    Her form of spending time with her is shopping, or watching TV. Never doing 'life experience things"...
  • gregglgreggl Posts: 21,594 Officer
    there are no jobs waiting for these kids. integrate her into a community. let her breathe and keep college in reserve for when she figures it out.

    who knows. her investment may end up being in her partner.
  • HeatwaveHeatwave Posts: 1,997 Captain
    Think the best way I could put it. My Girl needs some type of outside influence to get her motivated and build the desire to go out in the world other than lagging here in PSL... That isn't always easy to do. It would be hard for me to comment on someone else kid, their choice for college, not, etc. YOu kind of have to know the kid a little and their goals, personality and much more...

    Right now it is all guide, do this, do that....
  • gregglgreggl Posts: 21,594 Officer
    the useful half life of an expensive degree is super short now, outside of a tight group of full on professions.

    it's a hell of a shot to ask a kid to call, today :)

    Gotta be a better way that isn't some ticking clock with a huge bill at the end.
  • HeatwaveHeatwave Posts: 1,997 Captain
    greggl wrote: »
    there are no jobs waiting for these kids. integrate her into a community. let her breathe and keep college in reserve for when she figures it out.

    who knows. her investment may end up being in her partner.


    Oh brother... no thank you. She goes next year to a big florida (paid for) college or she never goes... If we dont push for it now, it will never happen... How many people have said, yea, going to comm. college this year and then next year to a big school. By then, they are of adult age and one argument with Mom sends her out the door (wanting to live on her own or with boyfriend). College is then in the rearview mirror to never be approached again.

    And how many times have we all heard, wish I stayed in college, wish my parents made me.... wish I could afford to go to college. You get one chance at this, that is it. I can understand from a college educated person posting on here.

    Pick a college, go, go to work, done !
    Or from someone that has done good without college writing "it is not really needed"
    Hundreds of views on this... Ours is in the middle I think, we really want her to go and know you only get one shot. Do it now or regret it later. I would think that is where most would fall.

    Again, CC will be over with and it is time to go on... for the connections, for the experience, for the growth which she needs badly...
  • gregglgreggl Posts: 21,594 Officer
    thats my wife's story. we met at an FSU frat party :)
  • duckmanJRduckmanJR Posts: 21,265 AG
    Heatwave wrote: »
    Sorry, just getting back to this.. As far as the CC goes, she will have a two year degree before she is out of high school from IRCC.. That is the good, the bad is that she only does anything of this because we push. She in NOT leading the way here. Her mother and I were both go getters, so to speak, but did so only after learning high school was not enough. We did not know each other then of course.

    Anyway, back to KID.. Great kid, and will do anything we ask, but that is it. Not much on the social side for getting out with others, making contacts, etc. That could have a lot to do with both parents working from home and making good money. She see's it as easy...

    Neither of us have any experience with making sure she gets all the money she can. I would think that there is something that offers that... No ?

    I think it would be best for her to learn this process on her own. With us just to guide a little, like others wrote, not really ready for big school. I know, if not now, it will never happen as I can see her NOT fighting hard for what she wants. I for one won't lay out each thing for her, somethings she needs to learn. On the other hand, my wife will say when frustrated watching our girl struggle with something, here, let me do it. THen say, see, that is how it is done. Bad bad experience for a kid and I keep stating such. She won't listen and wants to bring her up much slower than I do. It could be something as simple as cleaning the car. In place of working with her, she would rather tell her howe to do it, then complain when it isn't correct. I get frustrated with that stuff because I know spending time with her is much better.

    Her form of spending time with her is shopping, or watching TV. Never doing 'life experience things"...

    Kinda off the topic...but have you considered guiding her towards an enlistment in the military to let her "grow " a bit before committing to a career ? ...
    There are many roads to travel
    Many things to do.
    Knots to be unraveled
    'fore the darkness falls on you
  • cprcpr Posts: 9,299 Admiral
    duckmanJR wrote: »
    Kinda off the topic...but have you considered guiding her towards an enlistment in the military to let her "grow " a bit before committing to a career ? ...

    Good idea duck.

    BTW, If she's really smart the navy is desperate math geniuses for nuke stuff. They are offering great deals.

    If she needs motivation let her pay her cell phone bill, auto insurance, and so on. Or she goes to school and keeps sponging off mom and dad. My youngest just figured that out. He only wanted a AA, now he's thinking of milking the deal longer.
    "The test of a first-rate intelligence is the ability to hold two opposed ideas in the mind at the same time, and still retain the ability to function." F. Scott Fitzgerald

    "Prediction is very difficult, especially if it's about the future." Niels Bohr
  • HeatwaveHeatwave Posts: 1,997 Captain
    Been trying that and it would be fantastik. Her MOM is pushing opposite and of course say's "You'll get killed" Way off the path... We are actually very different in parenting styles. She is trying to protect, hide, etc. I on the other hand want her out there learning life...
    Hopefully she falls in the middle. Great kid, no trouble out of her at all. Too good sometimes... She won't stand up for herself, give an opinion, that kind of stuff...

    In the end, it will all work out, one way or another and she will be fine. As a parent you can't help but to worry...
  • team getterdunteam getterdun Posts: 1,741 Captain
    Heatwave wrote: »
    Think the best way I could put it. My Girl needs some type of outside influence to get her motivated and build the desire to go out in the world other than lagging here in PSL... That isn't always easy to do.

    Right now it is all guide, do this, do that....

    Why send her off to the Air Force or Navy for the next 4 years?
    "Fundamentals are nothing but a crutch for the talentless" - Kenny Powers
  • gregglgreggl Posts: 21,594 Officer
    Training manuals are written at a 7th grade level and unemployment for recent vets is horrible...

    is this still the option it once was?
  • team getterdunteam getterdun Posts: 1,741 Captain
    It may provide her the opportunity to determine what she wants to do, and the money she will receive for college is fantastic.
    "Fundamentals are nothing but a crutch for the talentless" - Kenny Powers
  • gregglgreggl Posts: 21,594 Officer
    does data point to that still being the case? it seems to have a negative effect now
  • team getterdunteam getterdun Posts: 1,741 Captain
    "Fundamentals are nothing but a crutch for the talentless" - Kenny Powers
  • gregglgreggl Posts: 21,594 Officer
    employment... not schooling :)
Sign In or Register to comment.
Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!

SUBSCRIBE NOW

Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

Preview This Month's Issue

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Florida Sportsman App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Florida Sportsman stories delivered right to your inbox.

Advertisement

Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Florida Sportsman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit mymagnow.com and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now