Home› Ask the Law!

can i keep 2 snook if?

bocapup1bocapup1 Posts: 1,101 Officer
in Ask the Law! #1
im fishing the beach with my 13 year old daughter and she is with me.i have my salt water fishing license and snook stamp.does she need to catch one of the snook or can she just be chillin on her iphone?
· Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
«1

Replies

  • fish_stixfish_stix Posts: 1,371 Officer
    #2
    Sure, you can keep 2 snook, and in the process, you'll be teaching your kid how to violate the regs.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • anejo22anejo22 Posts: 1,511 Officer
    #3
    If she reels it in if not heck no
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • monoxidemonoxide Posts: 1,094 Officer
    #4
    She has to reel it in.

    On a side note my niece and nephew always want me to take them fishing if I were to cast out for them and hook the fish and let them land it are they able to keep it or is it considered mine since I casted and hooked it.
    ted.gif
    ted.gif
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • ANUMBER1ANUMBER1 Posts: 11,348 AG
    #5
    No different than some of the respected guides here that let their clients keep the "Guides" limit too.
    I am glad to only be a bird hunter with bird dogs...being a shooter or dog handler or whatever other niche exists to separate appears to generate far too much about which to worry.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • SJCSJC Posts: 2,571 Captain
    #6
    Short answer Yes.

    Ethical? Not really. What I mean by that is...If a FWC officer stops you and he asks her did you fish and then she looks at you with the "what do I say" look in her eyes then what?
    The Beatings will continue until moral improves!
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • DarcyDarcy Posts: 1,711 Captain
    #7
    SJC wrote: »
    Short answer Yes.

    Ethical? Not really. What I mean by that is...If a FWC officer stops you and he asks her did you fish and then she looks at you with the "what do I say" look in her eyes then what?
    good point
    but i also think its kind of unethical for a fwc officer to ask a 13 year old if they fished. knowing good well that you are forcing the child to tell the truth and get daddy in trouble, or to lie in order to protect daddy. no need to put a child in that predicament. just ask the parent.
    "No i'm NOT Darcizzle!":blowkiss


    https://captainsforcleanwater.org
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • Navy_FishingNavy_Fishing Posts: 817 Officer
    #8
    Darcy wrote: »
    good point
    but i also think its kind of unethical for a fwc officer to ask a 13 year old if they fished. knowing good well that you are forcing the child to tell the truth and get daddy in trouble, or to lie in order to protect daddy. no need to put a child in that predicament. just ask the parent.

    Really? The FWC officer is putting her in that position or was it the parent who put her in that position? The truth is never wrong.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • DarcyDarcy Posts: 1,711 Captain
    #9
    Navy_Fishing wrote: »
    Really? The FWC officer is putting her in that position or was it the parent who put her in that position? The truth is never wrong.
    i didnt say the fwc put her in that position to have to lie.. we all know who did but he is forcing her hand. I dont believe in this situation asking the child is absolutely necessary. Ask the responsible adult.
    "No i'm NOT Darcizzle!":blowkiss


    https://captainsforcleanwater.org
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • nicknick Crystal RiverPosts: 4,961 Captain
    #10
    bocapup1 wrote: »
    im fishing the beach with my 13 year old daughter and she is with me.i have my salt water fishing license and snook stamp.does she need to catch one of the snook or can she just be chillin on her iphone?

    It's not a question of "can i" It's a question of did you...:grin
    https://highoctanefishing.com/
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • bocapup1bocapup1 Posts: 1,101 Officer
    #11
    nick no way man just asking before i bring her beach fishing.this weekend i will hook her up and force her to fish the mullet schools with me and we will see what happens and thanks for the answer.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • Mako_OneMako_One Posts: 216 Officer
    #12
    Why don't you go to myfwc.com and see what the regs say. Why is everyone so lazy to do some leg work. Do you want to teach your 13 year old how daddy wants to break the law and cheat? Your pathetic!
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • Roc N RolRoc N Rol Posts: 1,352 Officer
    #13
    Cant you be happy with one snook? If your daughter doesn't like to fish forcing her will most likely make her hate fishing even more and hate going to the beach with you if she is going to be forced to fish. Take 2 aspirin and place a cold compress on your forehead, the bad case of snook fever you have will pass.
    Crazzzy Day Offshore Fishing Trip
    http://forums.floridasportsman.com/showthread.php?303-8-21-10-FPI-Crazzzy-Day-Offshore-Fishing-Trip
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • DarcyDarcy Posts: 1,711 Captain
    #14
    Mako_One wrote: »
    Why don't you go to myfwc.com and see what the regs say. Why is everyone so lazy to do some leg work. Do you want to teach your 13 year old how daddy wants to break the law and cheat? Your pathetic!

    Wow.
    "No i'm NOT Darcizzle!":blowkiss


    https://captainsforcleanwater.org
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • bocapup1bocapup1 Posts: 1,101 Officer
    #15
    just asking a question before i did anything.mako u need a time out
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • PoppopPoppop Posts: 181 Deckhand
    #16
    Navy_Fishing wrote: »
    Really? The FWC officer is putting her in that position or was it the parent who put her in that position? The truth is never wrong.
    I agree 100%. Even if you make a mistake. the truth will set you free but a lie lingers on.

    Poppop
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • ScoutboatScoutboat Posts: 2,374 Captain
    #17
    Come on, Dude!
    Is this what you want to teach your kid??
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • LODI QUACKERLODI QUACKER Posts: 149 Deckhand
    #18
    HA !!!!!!! This is funny! Everyone here lives in glass houses. I cant believe there are so many perfect people in Florida. Dam not what I have seen when I have been there. If you hook up on a fish that she can handle, hand her the rod and let her fight it in. Take pics so you have the girl fighting a real fish and you net it. Done. End of story. Now you can catch yourself one. She must participate in the fish catching, she doesnt have to do it solo.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • bocapup1bocapup1 Posts: 1,101 Officer
    #19
    i asked a question and after getting the correct answer i was all good,and then bashing for something i didnt do.go suck on something sour suckers!
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • DarcyDarcy Posts: 1,711 Captain
    #20
    bocapup1 wrote: »
    i asked a question and after getting the correct answer i was all good,and then bashing for something i didnt do.go suck on something sour suckers!

    Too funny. I like it.
    "No i'm NOT Darcizzle!":blowkiss


    https://captainsforcleanwater.org
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • kreidelkreidel Posts: 78 Deckhand
    #21
    To the OP I say just keep yours and teach your daughter how to respect our resources. It means a lot more when you earn it anyways.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • P.cliffordP.clifford Posts: 226 Officer
    #22
    Just remember how honest kids are. From the mouths of babes.................. I think you could be in a pickle. If you want to keep 2, teach the kid to fish. let her catch a legal one and keep it
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • JettyparkJettypark Posts: 1,969 Captain
    #23
    I love the part where some of you guy's actually think he is going to catch a slot snook and better yet "Two" slot snooks..
    IMO if you hook up and gave her the rod to fight it/land it... and its a Slot>>>> take it home...

    I would be hard press to see a FWC Officer come up to you and give you the third degree on who caught
    the "SLOT" snook :grin

    Oh yea and didn't you know...Everybody on a forum is a Saint :willy-nilly

    You want to give her a lesson on people breaking rules>
    run to a boat ramp and watch some of their catches.. and
    if you really want to see it thrown in your face> Go to most
    fishing piers and be ready to watch all the honest folks
    there... LOL..
    aa13.gif"A ship without Marines is like a garment without buttons"
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • bocapup1bocapup1 Posts: 1,101 Officer
    #24
    for the last time i was asking a question and i got the answer so this thread should be dead but no too many butt-plugs on here with nothing better to do!grab your rods and go catch some fish already....out
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • Pucker FactorPucker Factor Posts: 875 Officer
    #25
    bocapup1 wrote: »
    butt-plugs to catch some fish

    I've been snook fishing for a few years. Is this a diver, suspending or top water plug and do these types of plugs work?
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • Mako_OneMako_One Posts: 216 Officer
    #26
    If you got your answer, why do you continue to watch and post. is your conscience getting to you??
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • Rich MRich M Posts: 1,326 Officer
    #27
    Gotta love the internet police... LOL!

    I've always fished with my dad. Used to catch the fish too. YES is your answer, if she doesn't need a license that's okay but she can keep the legal fish she catches. Just get her to reel it in anyway and that's about all they want to do anyway.

    Would I keep 2 reds if taking a 6 yr old out fishing? You betcha and the kid would probably reel both of 'em in. Perfectly legal, legit, and ethically/morally acceptable to me.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • Fish HaidFish Haid Posts: 8,417 Admiral
    #28
    Maybe the fish cop was hiding and watched you catch both. Then, when you and the girl both lie about it, you both get felony arrests for obstruction of justice.
    23895.gif
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • snookerf150snookerf150 Posts: 298 Officer
    #29
    These people are funny, i wonder how many of you go out grouper fishing and after their limit is in the box put their rod in the holder and say "well i cant fish anymore you guys have to catch your own limits" Or go lobstering and stop at their limit climb in the boat and watch the rest of their team continue. bunch of jokers here i tell ya.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • fishdishfishdish Posts: 1,223 Officer
    #30
    You and your daughter are a team. Do what you think is best for the team. Ask her what she thinks. If she doesn't care and you don't feel guilty then there you go. You're not doing anything illegal. The regulation says "1 per harvester". They don't define harvester in detail so if she's with you and you want to keep it then legally you are OK. From a personal standpoint, when I take my 8 year old daughter out she fishes but rarely catches a slot size fish. I have no problem keeping "our" bag limit if I am going to eat them within 48 hours. And yes I ask her if she wants to keep them........ Unless my wife says otherwise before we leave.
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
  • bocapup1bocapup1 Posts: 1,101 Officer
    #31
    well I was at the boat ramp today and asked the fwc personally about this question and this is what he said with a stone cold face so here it goes.the fisherman or fishergirl must hook there own bait,cast on there own or flip the bail,set the hook and fight the fish plus retrieve it to make it a legal catch.asked if they have been catching and with the same stone cold face he replies cocaine and marijuana :USA
    · Share on TwitterShare on Facebook
Sign In or Register to comment.