Skip to main content
Home Sportsman's Kitchen

Fresh (read... fresh, not wild) rainbow trout... AMAZINGLY GOOD!

Panhandler80Panhandler80 Posts: 8,928 Moderator
We hit up a trout farm and it was a good thing that after about 20 minutes we counted the fish... we were sitting on 17 total and that adds up pretty quickly. The folks advised that we cook them whole, which I was not wild about. I'm also not wild about salmon and this stuff looked and smelled like salmon.

Here's my buddy with one of the fish that I believe he "caught" on a bare hook... Don't ask me why he looks so "funny" here... not funny Ha-Ha....

If you look closely you'll see yours truly also tied into an elusive monster. Still fun and after you've walked main street once, hiked the easiest / coolest trails and been gem mining... what else are you going to do? Plus I had not caught a fish in almost three weeks so I was getting little batty!

Back at the house...

The trout farmers said not to filet, or try to skin. Just cook like it is and the meat will just flake right off the bones. They said something about them being genetically engineered to do this. I believe it because this fish were not natural looking. THat being said, I was a big skeptical, but I figured what the heck! Although I was a bit worried that we had no other food in the fridge if this was a disaster.


We laid each fish in its own foil boat on top of some cavendars, a touch of cayenne, some lemon slices, lemon juice, sea salt and whole pepper corns. On top was cavenders, butter and EVOO. Put on grill and it was time to eat. All the while, I'm nervous as a cat. They just smelled / looked / felt so much different than the saltwater fish I'm used to. WE'll see!


Terrible picture, but the fish was AMAZING. We had it with some kind of olivada type topping that I was not wild about, along with roasted red pepper and grilled zucchini spears. Good meal, but GREAT fish. I have never had a fish that oily that was not also strong. It stayed moist and was just a real pleasure to eat.


This was Sunday night. We got back to the house around 6:00 pm on Monday and ate some thawed out chili before getting some rest for work the next day. We had like 9 fish left, so we cooked three of them Tuesday night and I was certain they would have either gone bad, or just weren't that great to begin with and I was confusing too many adult beverages with good eats.

Cooked them again at home the exact same way on Tuesday, and STILL AWESOME!

Here was Round 2 in Panama City....


Here's what I did with my FIRST fish that night. Keep in mind, I'm really not all that wild about most fish...


Really good stuff.

SO... on Wed we still had some left over. Gave three to my parents and I think two more to my wife's parents then. They ate on Wed and Thursday night and said they couldn't get enough either! Crazy. I wish I could raise some here. I know it's about like comparing a wild turkey to Popeyes... but guess what, they're both darn good!
"Whatcha doin' in my waters?"


  • Permit RatPermit Rat Posts: 2,283 Captain
    Great story. I cut my teeth on trout fishing in New England, now almost 60 years ago. First of all, your trout were not genetically engineered to have the meat fall off the bones when cooked right. Second, if your trout were not "natural looking," you may be referring to them missing parts of their fins, most notably the tail, and this would be because whereas you caught them in a stream or pond, they were hatched and raised in cement tanks....and cramped very tightly together, I might add. So just think of this as the trout version of "road rash."

    On flavor: I'm with you on this. The only wild trout I really like (REALLY like!) are the little 4-5" brookies that often take a hook very deep, such that they would probably bleed to death if they were released. These I would save and clean and freeze after each outing. When I had 8 or 9 of them, I would roll them in corn meal and fry them in bacon grease....a little overdone by our standards....and serve with the usual eggs, fried potatoes, bacon, etc.. The idea is that these fish are so tiny that you can pick them up by the head and eat the whole thing, bones and all....just like a sardine.

    But other than that, wild trout are not a great eating fish in my opinion. BUT...hatchery fish are much cleaner and less oily tasting. I learned this in Missouri, some time ago. This is because of the trout pellets (trout chow) that they are fed. This is largely a vegetarian diet with artificial proteins added. There are none of the natural proteins and fats that are inherent in insect bodies, which are the mainstay diet for a wild trout the size that you caught.

    Sorry to say that I am not a great fan of steamed fish. But other than that, I am glad you enjoyed the fish and I empathize with you on the flavor.
Sign In or Register to comment.
Magazine Cover

GET THE MAGAZINE Subscribe & Save

Digital Now Included!


Give a Gift   |   Subscriber Services

Preview This Month's Issue

Buy Digital Single Issues

Don't miss an issue.
Buy single digital issue for your phone or tablet.

Buy Single Digital Issue on the Florida Sportsman App

Other Magazines

See All Other Magazines

Special Interest Magazines

See All Special Interest Magazines

GET THE NEWSLETTER Join the List and Never Miss a Thing.

Get the top Florida Sportsman stories delivered right to your inbox.


Phone Icon

Get Digital Access.

All Florida Sportsman subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets.

To get started, click the link below to visit and learn how to access your digital magazine.

Get Digital Access

Not a Subscriber?
Subscribe Now